Author: Dev Patel | EQMint | General News

Mumbai, October 30 — Shares of debt-laden telecom operator Vodafone Idea Ltd (Vi) plunged over 12% in intraday trade on Thursday following the Supreme Court’s order that granted the company only partial relief in the long-running Adjusted Gross Revenue (AGR) case. The ruling restricted the scope of relief to demands raised for the period up to FY2016–17, dampening investor sentiment and reigniting concerns about the company’s financial sustainability.

The telecom stock hit an intra-day low of ₹8.21 on the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE), compared to its previous closing price of ₹9.37. The sharp decline erased a significant portion of the recent gains Vodafone Idea had recorded amid optimism over potential government relief measures and its ongoing fundraising efforts.

Supreme Court Order: Relief Limited to Pre-2017 AGR Demands

In its written order, the Supreme Court clarified that Vodafone Idea’s plea pertains only to the “additional AGR demand” raised by the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) for the period ending FY2016–17. Analysts noted that the decision effectively caps the scope of the company’s relief to around ₹9,450 crore — a fraction of its total AGR-related liabilities.

“It is further to be noted that the prayer in the petition itself restricts its claim only to the additional AGR demand raised by the respondent for the period up to the Financial Year 2016–17,”
the apex court stated in its order.

The Supreme Court also made it clear that this order applies solely to Vodafone Idea, noting that it is based on the “peculiar facts and circumstances” of the case presented by the Union of India. This clarification dealt a minor setback to Bharti Airtel, whose shares also declined nearly 1.5% during Thursday’s session.

“We further clarify that this order is passed only with regard to the petitioner-Vodafone Idea Ltd., taking into consideration the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case as put up by the Union of India,”
the court added.

AGR Overhang: A Mounting Financial Burden

The latest ruling does little to alleviate Vodafone Idea’s deep financial distress. The company continues to grapple with a staggering ₹83,400 crore in AGR dues and total government liabilities exceeding ₹2 trillion, including spectrum payments and interest obligations.

Analysts caution that the restricted scope of relief means the telecom operator’s balance sheet will remain severely stretched, despite ongoing efforts to raise capital and improve cash flows.

Vodafone Idea, jointly promoted by the Vodafone Group Plc and Aditya Birla Group, has repeatedly warned that the massive debt burden threatens its long-term viability, placing at risk not only its operations but also the livelihoods of its 18,000 employees and its 198 million subscribers across India.

Analysts’ View: Partial Relief Insufficient for Revival

According to Emkay Global Financial Services, even excluding AGR dues, Vodafone Idea’s debt stands at around ₹1.18 trillion, most of which relates to spectrum liabilities. The brokerage noted that this level of leverage is unsustainable, given the company’s current EBITDA of ₹92 billion in FY25 (excluding IndAS-116 impact).

Emkay said that while the Supreme Court’s order may marginally improve the company’s revival prospects, the relief remains limited, and uncertainty continues to loom over the government’s stance on restructuring the spectrum-related debt.

“Given high leverage, elevated valuations, and lack of clarity on the government’s approach toward spectrum liabilities, we continue to maintain a SELL rating on Vodafone Idea stock with a target price of ₹6,”
the brokerage added.

Market experts also highlighted that the government’s future policy decisions could determine whether the company can sustain operations or head toward further financial distress. “The GoI will need to take a holistic view of the sector’s solvency, especially in light of Vodafone Idea’s strategic role in maintaining market competition,” one analyst commented.

Background: Vodafone Idea’s Legal Challenge

The Supreme Court case stems from a petition filed by Vodafone Idea on September 8, contesting a fresh demand of ₹9,450 crore raised by the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) for the period up to FY2018–19. The demand included ₹2,774 crore attributed to Vodafone Idea (post-merger) and ₹6,675 crore related to legacy Vodafone Group entities.

In its filing, Vodafone Idea argued that a substantial portion — approximately ₹5,606 crore as of March 31, 2025 — pertained to the period up to FY2016–17, which had already been finalized (“crystallized”) by the Supreme Court in its earlier judgments. The telecom operator maintained that these amounts should not be re-assessed and sought relief from additional penalties and interest on disputed sums.

The company also requested the court to consider the “dire financial implications” of any new demands, emphasizing that it had already cleared substantial dues in compliance with previous rulings.

Market Reaction and Broader Implications

Thursday’s market reaction underscores investors’ concerns about the limited scope of judicial relief and the lack of visibility around a comprehensive government rescue plan. While the partial relief could provide short-term breathing room, it does not significantly alter the company’s financial fundamentals.

Investors and analysts alike believe that Vodafone Idea’s survival depends heavily on sustained capital infusion, regulatory flexibility, and structural reforms in India’s telecom sector. The company has been exploring multiple avenues to raise funds, including equity issuances, asset monetization, and strategic partnerships, but progress has been slow amid investor skepticism.

In contrast, competitors Reliance Jio and Bharti Airtel continue to strengthen their balance sheets, widen market share, and accelerate 5G deployments — leaving Vodafone Idea struggling to keep pace.

The Road Ahead

With nearly ₹2 trillion in total liabilities, Vodafone Idea faces a monumental challenge in maintaining network quality, expanding 4G coverage, and meeting payment obligations. The Supreme Court’s order, while providing procedural clarity, offers little comfort on the larger solvency question.

Analysts argue that a comprehensive government intervention — potentially involving debt restructuring, spectrum payment moratoriums, or equity conversion of dues — will be crucial for Vodafone Idea’s revival. Until such clarity emerges, the company’s shares are expected to remain under pressure.

Despite its struggles, Vodafone Idea continues to command a significant subscriber base and national footprint, making its stability critical for ensuring competition in India’s telecom market.

Conclusion

Vodafone Idea’s sharp stock decline reflects a harsh market assessment: the Supreme Court’s partial relief is not enough to offset years of financial strain, mounting debt, and operational uncertainty. While the ruling may slightly ease immediate legal pressure, the telecom operator remains at a crossroads — balancing between survival and insolvency.

Without substantial policy support or fresh capital, the company’s future remains uncertain. For investors, Thursday’s sell-off was a stark reminder that the path to Vodafone Idea’s turnaround will likely be long, complex, and fraught with risk.

For more such information visit EQMint

Disclaimer: This article is based on information available from public sources. It has not been reported by EQMint journalists. EQMint has compiled and presented the content for informational purposes only and does not guarantee its accuracy or completeness. Readers are advised to verify details independently before relying on them.